I've lived in Indiana since the early 1970's, which makes me a Hoosier resident longer than any other kind of resident. Still, I have no Indiana lineage older than that, so I can't qualify for the Indiana Pioneers or the Territorial Guard Society.
I have a hunch there's a lot of folks in that same category, and who just might be interested in a new group coming up from the Ohio Genealogical Society. You don't have to be an OGS member, and the parameters give you lots of qualifying acreage. Might be a fun thing to look into.